Find us at Mitchell Road Antiques Centre

for more vintage toys and collectables

View products

VIEW PRODUCTS

View products

VIEW MLP products

Unlock Your Best Childhood Memories

Not your average toy store

What we do

New toys that have high play value

Action Figures & Collectables

Vintage Toys

Your favourite childhood toys from the 80s, 90s and 2000s.

Alfy's Vintage Collection

Shop address and Hours

Shop 7, 233 Harris Street PYRMONT Sydney

Now also at MITCHELL ROAD ANTIQUES CENTRE 17 Bourke Road Alexandria (Mon-Sun 10am-6pm) Check for holiday hours

Pyrmont Shop and online Christmas Closure 21/12-6/1 - click for more details

Pyrmont Shop Hours - January 2026:

Wed 7/1 - Sat 10/1 11am-2pm

Then back to 11am-2pm everyday except Thursday and Sunday from 12/1/26.

Closed Public Holidays.

Directions

An invitation to "play"

You will find the most treasured toys from the past and present at Alfy's New & Vintage Toy Shop. Be in awe at our unique collection of toys that will take you back in time, and help you rediscover your best childhood memories. Bring your children and create new memories that will last a lifetime!

Action Figures | Latest additions

Star Wars - Revenge of the Sith - Anakin Skywalker Changes to Darth Vader Deluxe Pack (2005)

$49.90

TMNT - FOOT SOLDIER Page Punchers 5" Figure with Comic (Wave 1)

$49.90

TMNT - SHREDDER Page Punchers 5" Figure with Comic (Wave 1)

$49.90

TMNT - LEONARDO Page Punchers 5" Figure with Comic (Wave 1)

$49.90

TMNT - DONATELLO Page Punchers 5" Figure with Comic (Wave 1)

$49.90

The Goonies - Mezco 5-points 3.75" Action Figures Set of 5

$249.90

Pee-Wee Herman Ultimate 7" scale Action Figure

$59.90

TMNT - Cartoon SHREDDER Ultimate 7″ Scale Action FIgure

$79.90

TMNT - Cartoon Samurai PANDA KAHN Ultimate 7″ Scale Action FIgure

$79.90

Halloween 6 - Curse of Michael Myers - Ultimate 7″ scale Action Figure

$79.90

Alien: Romulus - Ultimate Xenomorph XX121 7" Scale Action Figure

$99.90

Freddy Kruger Glove

$29.90

Beetlejuice (1988) - Blck & White Striped Suit - 7" scale Action Figure

$59.90

Nightmare on Elm St 3 - Dream Warriors FREDDY - 8" Clothed Figure

$89.90

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Re-Ignition Basic Figure - GREEN RANGER

$29.90

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Re-Ignition Basic Figure - BLACK RANGER

$24.90

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Re-Ignition Basic Figure - PINK RANGER

$24.90

Mighty Morphin Power Rangers Re-Ignition Basic Figure - YELLOW RANGER

$24.90

View all

RETRO MY LITTLE PONY

My Little Pony - SUNBEAM Original 1983 Collection Retro (2018)

$59.90

My Little Pony - TWILIGHT Original 1983 Collection Retro (2018)

$99.90

Erstwilder - My Little Pony (G1) MEGAN Brooch

$49.90

Erstwilder - My Little Pony (G1) STARSHINE Necklace

$149.90

My Little Pony - 40th Anniversary Plush - Full Carton of 4

Sale

My Little Pony - 40th Anniversary Plush - Full Carton of 4

$149.90 $159.90

My Little Pony - FIREFLY - 40th Anniversary Plush

$39.90

My Little Pony - G1 Megan, Skydancer & Parasol Castle Wallet by Loungefly

$59.90

My Little Pony - Earth Ponies BOW TIE Bowtie (Series 2) Wave 4

$59.90

My Little Pony - Earth Ponies (Wave 4) Collection of 4

$119.90

My Little Pony - Earth Ponies TOOTSIE (Series 2) Wave 4

$29.90

My Little Pony - Earth Ponies CHERRY JUBILEE (Series 2) Wave 4

$29.90

View all

Lego | Latest Additions

LEGO 2516 Ninjago Ninja Training Outpost (2011)

$100.00

LEGO 853687 Ninjago Minifigs 3-pack (2017)

$100.00

LEGO 853744 DC Super Heroes Knightmare Batman Minifigs 3-Pack (2018)

$65.00

LEGO 853570 City Police Minifigs 4-pack (2016)

$60.00

LEGO 853556 Friends Campsite Dolls Minifigs 3-pack (2016)

$45.00

LEGO - 76308 Marvel Spider-Man Mech vs Anti-Venom

$25.00

LEGO - 76307 Marvel Iron Man Mech vs. Ultron

$25.00

LEGO - 75412 Star Wars Death Trooper & Night Trooper Battle Pack

$29.90

LEGO - 75411 Star Wars Darth Maul Mech

$25.00

LEGO - 75400 Star Wars Plo Koon's Jedi Starfighter™ Microfighter

$25.00

LEGO - 43264 Disney Toy Story Celebration Train & RC Car

$59.90

LEGO - 10456 DUPLO McQueen's Visit to Doc's Garage

$39.90

View all

Grapat's Wooden Toys | Hand Made in Spain

Grapat - Christmas Advent Calendar 2024

$169.90

Grapat - Mis & Match Cubes & Sorting Box

$114.90

Grapat - Dear UNIVERSE

$88.90

Grapat - Lucky Lucky (Third Edition) Full Set of 15 Blind Boxes

Sale

Grapat - Lucky Lucky (Third Edition) Full Set of 15 Blind Boxes

$299.90
Sold Out $337.50

Grapat - Lucky Lucky (Second Edition) Full Set of 15 Blind Boxes

Sale

Grapat - Lucky Lucky (Second Edition) Full Set of 15 Blind Boxes

$299.90 $337.50

Grapat - Mandala Pumpkins

$32.90

Grapat - Mandala Rainbow Flower

$30.90
Sold Out

Grapat - Happy Place

$99.90

Grapat - Fancy Nins

$84.90
Sold Out

Grapat - LO (Half of Grapat Lola)

$94.90

Grapat Insects - New Release 2021

$56.90

Grapat Little Things Red - Wooden Toys

$25.90

View all

Plush

Sale

Shaun the Sheep - TIMMY Soft Toy

$32.90 $39.90

Sesame Street - Elmo Activity Toy

$28.90

Sesame Street - Cookie Monster Baby Comfort Blanket

$24.90

Peanuts Snoopy Large Soft Toy Plush

$44.90

Peter Rabbit - Classic Soft Plush Large 30cm

$44.90

Peter Rabbit - Mrs Rabbit Plush 25cm

$35.90

Peter Rabbit - Flopsy Bunny Plush 25cm

$35.90

Peter Rabbit - Jemima Puddle-duck Plush 25cm

$35.90

Care Bears x Wicked - Good Luck Bear as Elphaba Small Plush

$25.00

Care Bears x Wicked - Small Plushes - Full Set of 5

$124.90

Sesame Street - Snuffleupagus Soft Toy

$42.90

Micro Care Bears - Minis Set of 6 Wave 4

From $10.00

View all